World Rugby 'disappointed' after Scotland threaten legal action

Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend
Scotland head coach Gregor Townsend

World Rugby has expressed disappointment on the Scottish Rugby Union as they threatened to initiate legal action against the governing body to ensure their World Cup game against Japan goes ahead.

The game on Sunday hangs in the balance with the officials have scheduled an inspection at 22:00 BST on Saturday to decide on the fate of the encounter at the aftermath of Super Typhoon Hagibis. A cancelled result would mean Scotland will be eliminated from the tournament with Ireland expected to win their game against Samoa.

With World Rugby deciding against shifting the game to a different venue due to logistical reasons, Scottish Rugby chief executive Mark Dodson reasoned that the game should be allowed to play on Monday if the conditions were not suitable considering the importance of the contest.

"World Rugby have pointed us back to the participation agreement and that it is clearly stated there. We've had a legal opinion and then we've taken a leading sports QC opinion in London that challenges that and unravels the World Rugby case," said Dodson.

"We don't want to get in some sort of legal arm wrestle with World Rugby, but our view is it doesn't sit right with us, we don't feel it's just, we feel there's other ways.

"I think most people feel that if it had been an economic powerhouses - let's say New Zealand - perhaps more thought would have been given to a flexible approach.

"I think in the court of public opinion, we've already won. Right from the get go, we said we will play any place, anywhere, behind closed doors, in full stadiums. We will travel the length and breadth of Japan.

"We have spoken to the Japan Rugby Football Union and they are keen for this game to go on. What we're asking for is a common-sense approach that allows this game to be played in perfect safety 24 hours after the storm clears."

Reacting to Dodson's comments, World Rugby issued a statement pointing out Section 5.3 of the agreement signed by all the participating unions which stated that the games cannot be postponed to a different day.

"It is disappointing that the Scottish Rugby Union should make such comments at a time when we are doing everything we can to enable all Sunday's matches to take place as scheduled, and when there is a real and significant threat to public safety owing to what is predicted to be one of the largest and most destructive typhoons to hit Japan since 1958.

"Along with the 19 other teams, the Scottish Rugby Union signed the Rugby World Cup 2019 terms of participation, which clearly state in Section 5.3: 'Where a pool match cannot be commenced on the day in which it is scheduled, it shall not be postponed to the following day, and shall be considered as cancelled. In such situations, the result shall be declared a draw and teams will be allocated two match points each and no score registered.'

"As outlined during Thursday's media conference in Tokyo, the core principle that could enable us to explore a departure from the terms of participation, is a fair and consistent application of the rescheduling for all teams in a safe environment for teams, fans and essential match services.

"The sheer predicted scale and impact of the typhoon, and the complexity of team movements for eight matches, meant that an even-handed application was just not possible without putting safety at risk.

"Therefore, it was the fair and correct decision for all teams to maintain the position outlined in the terms of participation.

"It would be inappropriate to make further comment at a time when we are fully focused on the safety of everyone and this weekend's matches."

Scotland Fixtures


Scotland Results