If Internationals were Picked on Form... The Rugby Championship

If Internationals were Picked on Form...
©Max Skofic

Talking Rugby Union’s very own man down-under, Scotty Donaldson, in his latest article looks past international frequency and picks his Rugby Championship teams, based purely on Super Rugby form.

2013 saw the inaugural Rugby Championship competition play-out to great success, after Argentina joined the Tri-Nations to create the competition we have today…

With international test match rugby just around the corner, the Rugby Championship teams – including New Zealand, Australia and South Africa – have, or will be naming their squads for the June International test matches.  

It is interesting comparing team selections with their Super Rugby statistics which has given us "Form XV"s for the All Blacks, Wallabies and Springboks, and it is interesting to see how many of these players gained selection in the actual international training squads.

The All Black’s Form XV features 11 players who made the All Blacks training squad out of 15.

It is interesting to see the Hurricanes dominating the tight-five, which is scary given their usual reputation for having a soft underbelly.  

Interestingly, Colin Slade is the form Number 10 in New Zealand ahead of Beauden Barrett; while Nademe Nadolo who isn't eligible for New Zealand has just pipped Julian Savea.  

The Wallabies and Springboks squads will be named soon and it will be interesting to see if they pick on form or reputation.  

The Australian Form XV is probably not too far from the likely Wallabies squad, while the South African Form XV doesn't require too many big names, so it will be interesting to see how many form players make the Springboks.

 

Who do you think should make the Springboks, All Blacks and Wallabies and should it be based on form or reputation?

We've crunched the numbers by country and come up with the best starting fifteen for each. 

How does this compare with the players being selected for the international window?

This squads have been picked entirely on Super Rugby fantasy points earned from the series to date.

The calculation only includes the starting 15 of each week, and a player must have started at least 5 games in their position.

The position they most commonly played is the position they are considered for, and only games played in that position contribute toward the calculation.

Also, there has been no attempt to filter out import players - they show for the country in which their Super Rugby team represents.

What do you think..?

 

South Africa:

Player

Team

Country

Position

Fantasy
Avg

Fantasy
Total

Actual
Points

 

Dean Greyling

BUL

South Africa

1 - Prop - Loose

131

1575

0

 

Bismarck- du-Plessis

SHK

South Africa

2 - Hooker

267

2675

0

 

Frans Malherbe

STM

South Africa

3 - Prop -Tight

179

1615

10

 

Paul willemse

BUL

South Africa

4 - Lock

181

1270

5

 

Victor Matfield

BUL

South Africa

5 - Lock

204

1840

0

 

Nizaam Carr

STM

South Africa

6 - Loose Blindside

250

1505

10

 

Jean Deysel

SHK

South Africa

7 - Loose Openside

275

1375

5

 

Phillip van-der-Walt

CHE

South Africa

8 - Loose Number 8

262

1575

5

 

Cobus Reinach

SHK

South Africa

9 - Halfback

195

1170

10

 

Jacques-Louis Potgieter

BUL

South Africa

10 - Fly-half

243

1945

103

 

Courtnall- Skosan

LIO

South Africa

11 - Wing Left

216

1080

15

 

Damian- de-Allende

STM

South Africa

12 - Centre Inside

227

1135

5

 

Lionel Mapoe

LIO

South Africa

13 - Centre Outside

210

1260

10

 

Cornal Hendricks

CHE

South Africa

14 - Wing Right

172

1380

15

 

Willie Le-Roux

CHE

South Africa

15 - Fullback

270

1895

10

 

 

Australia:

Player

Team

Country

Position

Fantasy
Avg

Fantasy
Total

Actual
Points

 

James Slipper

RED

Australia

1 - Prop - Loose

178

1430

5

 

Stephen Moore

BRM

Australia

2 - Hooker

230

2305

5

 

Kieran Longbottom

FOR

Australia

3 - Prop -Tight

119

1195

0

 

Rob Simmons

RED

Australia

4 - Lock

179

1975

10

 

Luke Jones

REB

Australia

5 - Lock

222

2000

0

 

Jacques Potgieter

WAR

Australia

6 - Loose Blindside

251

1255

5

 

Micheal Hooper

WAR

Australia

7 - Loose Openside

239

2395

5

 

Ben McCalman

FOR

Australia

8 - Loose Number 8

270

2430

15

 

Luke Burgess

REB

Australia

9 - Halfback

148

890

5

 

Bernard Foley

WAR

Australia

10 - Fly-half

273

2735

117

 

Nick Cummins

FOR

Australia

11 - Wing Left

221

2210

30

 

Kurtley Beale

WAR

Australia

12 - Centre Inside

232

2090

21

 

Tamati Ellison

REB

Australia

13 - Centre Outside

190

1900

5

 

Joseph Tomane

BRM

Australia

14 - Wing Right

188

1320

10

 

Israel Folau

WAR

Australia

15 - Fullback

300

2100

45

 

 

New Zealand:

Player

Team

Country

Position

Fantasy
Avg

Fantasy
Total

Actual
Points

 

Ben Franks

HUR

New Zealand

1 - Prop - Loose

142

1280

5

 

Dane Coles

HUR

New Zealand

2 - Hooker

237

2610

5

 

Jeffery Toomaga-Allen

HUR

New Zealand

3 - Prop -Tight

160

1285

5

 

Jeremy Thrush

HUR

New Zealand

4 - Lock

190

1905

5

 

Sam Whitelock

CRU

New Zealand

5 - Lock

245

1965

0

 

Steven Luatua

BLU

New Zealand

6 - Loose Blindside

192

1155

5

 

Luke Braid

BLU

New Zealand

7 - Loose Openside

239

1915

0

 

Kieran Read

CRU

New Zealand

8 - Loose Number 8

240

1445

0

 

Aaron Smith

HGH

New Zealand

9 - Halfback

181

1815

20

 

Colin Slade

CRU

New Zealand

10 - Fly-half

330

2310

106

 

Nemani Nadolo

CRU

New Zealand

11 - Wing Left

326

1630

30

 

Ma'a Nonu

BLU

New Zealand

12 - Centre Inside

238

1190

5

 

Malakai Fekitoa

HGH

New Zealand

13 - Centre Outside

244

2200

25

 

Tim Nanai-Williams

CHF

New Zealand

14 - Wing Right

242

1695

15

 

Ben Smith

HGH

New Zealand

15 - Fullback

273

2735

15

 

 
 
 
 
 

2019 Rugby World Cup Points Table