The Wallabies’ recent performance against Fiji was a match soaked in symbolism echoes of past failures, tension in key moments, and an overwhelming sense of missed opportunities.
Australia started strong, showing glimpses of a cohesive game plan, but as the match wore on, the cracks began to show. Once the structure began to unravel, so did their confidence, and Fiji, with their relentless energy and physicality, had the Wallabies playing off the back foot for much of the contest.
One of the more noticeable characteristics of this current Wallabies squad is their increased reliance on structured play a notable shift from previous generations of Australian teams known for their flair and unpredictability. But structure without leadership can quickly turn rigid. When the patterns broke down, there was hesitation, second-guessing, and a lack of direction.
At the heart of this issue lies a recurring problem: the fly-half position. The Wallabies have struggled to lock down a consistent and dependable number 10, and with Noah Lolesio sidelined due to injury, the question of who should steer the ship has become even more urgent.
The Bernard Foley Question
The answer, however, may be hiding in plain sight: Bernard Foley.
Foley, often overlooked in recent seasons, has quietly been proving his worth in Japan’s top league. In the past three seasons, he’s appeared in two Japanese Top League finals and was even named Player of the Year in one of those campaigns. That kind of pedigree doesn’t happen by accident. He’s not just a steady hand, he’s a proven game manager who understands how to control tempo, marshal his forwards, and bring out the best in the players around him.
For too long, Australian rugby has been obsessed with unearthing “the next big thing.” While youth and potential are vital, there’s undeniable value in experience, especially when matches hang in the balance. Foley’s success overseas, and how he is deeply respected overseas , reflective of his value, this should be enough evidence that he’s still got what it takes to perform on the biggest stage.
Depth, Maturity, and Calm
With Lolesio out, some voices are suggesting James O’Connor as potential solutions. Yes, O’Connor was part of the Crusaders setup, but let’s be honest: the Crusaders would have lifted that trophy with or without him.
So what’s the alternative? For my money, a smart, balanced squad should include a trio of experienced playmakers: Bernard Foley, James O’Connor, and Beale. These are players who’ve been there before. Players who know how to steady the ship when the pressure mounts.
The reality is, when things started to unravel against Fiji, the Wallabies looked lost. They needed someone to bring calm to the chaos, someone with a cool head and a deep understanding of game management. Foley provides exactly that.
Why Is Schmidt Hesitant?
It’s baffling why head coach Joe Schmidt seems so reluctant to call on Foley and other seasoned veterans. Perhaps it’s a desire to build for the future or to instill a fresh culture. But elite rugby isn’t just about long-term planning it’s also about winning the next match. And right now, Australia needs leaders on the field.
The Wallabies don’t just need structure. They need voices who can guide that structure under pressure. If Schmidt is serious about turning this team around, then Bernard Foley deserves more than just a second look he deserves the keys to the backline.
