Borthwick defends England's tactics after Calcutta Cup victory
Steve Borthwick has defended his side’s tactical approach after their 16-15 victory over Scotland
©PA
England coach Steve Borthwick has defended his side’s tactical approach after their 16-15 victory over Scotland secured the Calcutta Cup for the first time since 2020.
The win keeps England in the hunt for the Six Nations title, but criticism has mounted over their kick-heavy game plan.
Despite the victory, frustration was evident among home fans, with boos ringing out at Twickenham when scrum-half Alex Mitchell launched another box kick early in the second half.
England’s conservative style contrasted sharply with Scotland’s attacking flair, as the visitors outscored England three tries to one—though crucially, none of Scotland’s tries were converted.
Borthwick acknowledged the criticism but emphasized that his side executed the game plan necessary to secure victory.
“It’s not necessarily how we wish to play, but there are two teams out there and we found a way to win. I know often in terms of the commentary everyone talks about one team [England], but we respect there were two teams on the pitch.”
The former England captain stressed the challenge of breaking down Scotland’s defensive structure, highlighting their effectiveness in disrupting England’s rhythm.
“I’ve been very clear that I want the team to play with ball in hand, to attack with it, to be brave and aggressive, but there is another team trying to stop you – and they [Scotland] are pretty good at it.”
Borthwick pointed out that the game turned into a tactical battle, requiring patience and adaptability.
“That was a completely different game to one that we played in most recent times, it was a real tactical arm-wrestle in the middle of the pitch. Ultimately, Scotland are strong in defence, strong at the breakdown and take the game to this kicking game.”
He maintained that decision-making was crucial in determining when to run the ball and when to opt for territory.
“You’ve got to be very good and very judicious about when you run the ball and I thought the players did it well. I’m pleased the team found a way to adapt and found a way to win.”
