Ben Kay: Maro Itoje leads & Marcus Smith starts

Steve Borthwick's selections, squad surprises, and England's Six Nations prospects

Itoje Over George: A Tactical Captaincy Call

With Jamie George sidelined through injury, Maro Itoje’s appointment as England captain feels natural. But it also suggests Borthwick sees Itoje as a more consistent on-field presence. Unlike George, whose leadership was crucial post-Farrell, Itoje rarely leaves the pitch, providing continuity for the full 80 minutes. The long-standing debate over Itoje’s captaincy suitability remains, but his leadership will truly be tested when England face adversity.

Borthwick’s Exit: Distraction or Strategic Clarity?

The RFU’s announcement that Steve Borthwick’s contract won’t extend beyond 2027 raises eyebrows. Some might view it as a lack of faith, but it could well be Borthwick’s own decision. Either way, it’s unlikely to affect morale—players focus on World Cup cycles, and two years is a long time away in rugby. By setting an end date now, the RFU may also be shielding Borthwick from mid-tournament speculation.

England’s Rising Stars: Who to Watch

Asher Opoku-Fordjour is the name on everyone’s lips, but young props face a steep learning curve. Fin Baxter’s initial impact stalled, but that’s part of development. England’s challenge is to maintain consistency while integrating new talent. Meanwhile, Ben Spencer and Gabriel Ibitoye might feel hard done by after missing out on selection.

England’s Game Plan in Dublin

Despite injuries, England must target Ireland’s scrum—a rare weak spot, but with veteran Tadhg Furlong out of action in the first Round, it's an area England could disrupt. Historically, their best wins in Dublin have come through aerial dominance. Freddie Steward, looking to erase bad memories from 2023, will be key. England’s attack isn’t firing at full capacity yet, so they’ll rely on interrupting Ireland’s structure and capitalizing on some broken play.

The No. 10 Conundrum: Smith or Ford?

Marcus Smith starts at fly-half, but Fin Smith is breathing down his neck. Marcus will feel the pressure of the bench, but this should raise his game and keep him on into the latter stages. George Ford’s experience is invaluable in camp, but with the World Cup in mind, now is the time to commit to a long-term playmaker. The challenge for Marcus will be adapting his club style to England’s broader attacking framework.

England faces a tough Six Nations, but Borthwick’s selections suggest a team evolving for the long term. Whether it pays off remains to be seen. Click to read the full interview here!