Fin Smith has chance to prove he belongs among rugby's elite against All Blacks

Fin Smith's qualities are clear, but can he prove his class consistently on the international stage?
©Lizzy Terry/TEZ.PHOTOG

Fin Smith has established himself as England's first-choice fly-half, but now comes the biggest test of his international career so far.

With the All Blacks arriving on Saturday, the Northampton Saints playmaker has an opportunity to prove he belongs among the world's elite at number 10.

After last Friday’s thriller in Paris, I found myself discussing who the best fly-half in the Nations Championship is. More importantly, if you were picking a team for a World Cup final tomorrow, who would you want wearing the number 10 shirt?

The conversation came after watching Antoine Dupont operate at both scrum-half and fly-half, making the demands of both positions look effortless, alongside an underwhelming performance from Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu.

Then there was Manie Libbok, who once again missed crucial points off the tee.

Looking at two of the competition’s leading sides, I would struggle to pick any of their fly-halves for a World Cup final. There is one caveat, however. Had Matthieu Jalibert not been injured, his form this year would make a compelling case for him being the best in the world. Beyond that, I found myself seriously considering Smith.

Putting together a list of fly-halves who can genuinely be described as world-class is not as straightforward as it might seem.

Finn Russell certainly belongs in the conversation, although he has not been at his best over the past six months.

Damian McKenzie, meanwhile, has arguably been the form fly-half of the past two months, producing sensational performances against Australia and Scotland in the number 10 shirt. He was equally impressive at full-back for the All Blacks during the summer.

New Zealand's Reuben Love has caught the eye,  but it may be too early to give him the world-class label.

You could say the same of Smith, but what do you actually look for in a world-class fly-half?

A strong kicking game out of hand, variety in their passing, the ability to take the ball to the line and put teammates into space, defensive resilience and, often, a reliable record off the tee.

At 24, Smith has already demonstrated many of those qualities. He helped England to victories over France and Scotland in his first two starts in last year's Six Nations, landed crucial penalties in both games, and he also put his body on the line throughout.

The real question is whether he can take control of a game and lead his side to victory against the very best. That is what makes Saturday the perfect opportunity.

His opposite number is likely to be McKenzie or Richie Mo’unga, with Beauden Barrett also among a New Zealand side boasting some of the finest playmakers the game has seen. To come out on top against that calibre of opposition, while standing out as the best fly-half on the pitch, would do wonders for Smith’s reputation at Test level.

And it is at international level where the next step matters most.

In England, Smith has established himself as the clear first choice. With George Ford struggling to make the desired impact last week against Japan and Steve Borthwick seemingly reluctant to use Marcus Smith in his favoured position, Fin has an opportunity to nail down the 10 jersey even further.

He is directing the attack for one of the most exciting attacking teams in the game, tackling like a back-rower and increasingly displaying the leadership qualities required at Test level. The shirt is beginning to look like his own.

Last year, Ford delivered a statement performance to lead England to a 33-19 victory over the All Blacks. Now it is Smith’s turn to do the same.

Even if he simply sticks to what he does best, allowing those around him to flourish, that could be enough. Give Will Joseph - reportedly in line to start after his five-try display against Japan - and Tommy Freeman space to attack, and England have the players to make the most of it.

Having toured with the British and Irish Lions and accumulated 20 England caps, Smith is no longer an emerging talent. He has established himself on the international stage.

But Saturday, and the finals weekend that follows, offers him the chance to make it undeniable to the rest of the rugby world that he belongs among the elite fly-halves in the game.